Showing posts with label Orwellian rhetoric. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Orwellian rhetoric. Show all posts

Sunday, January 25, 2026

For Trump, the Truth in Minneapolis Is What He Says It Is; The New York Times, January 25, 2026

 , The New York Times; For Trump, the Truth in Minneapolis Is What He Says It Is

"Twice since the start of the year, federal officers have gunned down protesters in Minneapolis with cellphone cameras rolling and twice President Trump and his lieutenants have rushed forward with a message to the American people: Don’t believe what you see with your own eyes.

Without waiting for facts, the Trump team has advanced one-sided narratives to justify each of the killings and demonize the victims. Renee Good, a mother of three, was engaged in “domestic terrorism” and “viciously ran over the ICE Officer,” they declared. Alex Pretti, an I.C.U. nurse at a veterans’ hospital, was an “assassin” aiming to “massacre law enforcement.”

The trick is that the Trump versions of reality have collided with bystander videos watched by millions who did not see what they were told. Ms. Good did not run over the ICE agent who killed her; a video analysis suggested she was trying to turn away from him and he continued to shoot her even as she passed him. Mr. Pretti approached officers with a phone in his hand, not a gun; he moved to help a woman who was pepper sprayed and he was under a pileup of agents when one suddenly shot him in the back.

The videos, sometimes shaky, incomplete or at a distance, may not show the totality of what happened in those confusing split seconds on the street and they do not speak to what was going through the heads of the officers who opened fire in what is being called self-defense. Many questions about exactly what happened remain unanswered and further investigation could change the understanding of the deadly events in Minneapolis, perhaps even bolstering the Trump administration’s assertions, but the administration is blocking independent inquiries."

A Call for Peace and Discernment: A Pastoral Letter from Bishop Scanlan; The Episcopal Diocese of the Susquehanna, January 25, 2026



[Kip Currier: Share with others the following letter by Bishop Audrey C. Scanlan.]


The Episcopal Diocese of the SusquehannaA Call for Peace and Discernment: A Pastoral Letter from Bishop Scanlan

Dear Members of the Episcopal Diocese of the Susquehanna,

In recent days the brightness of the Epiphany light has been obscured as division and discord in our nation has turned to deadly violence in our streets.  The events in Minneapolis – the killing of Renee Nicole Good by an ICE agent, this weekend’s shooting and killing of Alex Jeffrey Pretti by federal forces – and the ongoing illegal seizure and detention without due process of hundreds of individuals across our country call for us as citizens and Christians, to respond.

Woe to those who call evil good
and good evil,
who put darkness for light
and light for darkness,
who put bitter for sweet
and sweet for bitter!

Isaiah 5:20

These are grievous days in which the evil that Isaiah writes about is evident in our cities, villages, and in the hearts of those who do harm.  In the face of evil, God calls us to resist and to work, empowered by the Holy Spirit, to restore the peace and harmony that is God’s dream for us.

Many of us across the diocese are already engaged as peacemakers and reconcilers.  Our parishes are working to support the most vulnerable in our communities. Individuals are serving in ways that are both quiet and bold, reaching out one-on-one or to whole groups serving to repair the breach.  In the great prologue to John’s gospel, we read: “The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.” (John 1:5) While the light maybe obscured, it is not extinguished.  God’s love will prevail.

Today I call us to discernment. I invite a diocesan-wide practice to engage in prayerful reflection on God’s call to us, asking for affirmation of the ways that we are now serving and direction for the days ahead. This ancient Christian practice invites us to listen for God’s call to us as we follow the path of love.  United by the waters of baptism, each of us in our diocese – lay and clergy alike – is called to participate in God’s mission and to find our place that will bring us from heartbreak to healing.  Our nation needs us and our faith instructs us to do this work. Discernment is not a “one and done” event but an ongoing practice that reveals God’s will for us.

In my discernment in the past several months, I have heard God calling me to “stability.”  This monastic virtue is described by St. Benedict as a path of perseverance in the face of adversity and the refusal to flee when the community or self becomes uncomfortable. Benedict also points to stability as the place where conversion of life can take place. For me, stability means “showing up:” sitting each morning to read the scriptures and say my prayers, meeting with people in their own discernment even when answers are not yet evident, and remaining faithful to our pattern of worship, coming together to be nourished by the Sacraments. Stability means to stand in the face of evil and to proclaim God’s power and love.  

And now, God is calling us to discern some more.  To revisit our practices in the context of what is happening in our country today.   Through this practice God may affirm that what we are doing is holy and good and to keep at it, or God may reveal something new, something more for us to do.

I invite you to join me in discernment and to do this work individually or collectively, as a family or parish community. There are materials provided at the end of this letter to assist you in your prayer of discernment.  May your work be blessed as you find God’s call to you as an agent of peace.

If you would like to share the call that God has placed on your heart with our diocesan community, please email communications@diosusquehanna.org and we will keep a list on our website to invite ongoing prayers for our ministry together from now until we celebrate the paschal feast at Easter.

May God bless us and keep us and may the light of Christ shine in our hearts.

The Rt. Rev. Audrey C. Scanlan
Bishop Diocesan of The Diocese of the Susquehanna"

Saturday, April 29, 2023

War of words: The fight over banning books; CBS News, Sunday Morning, April 23, 2023

MARTHA TEICHNER, CBS News, Sunday Morning; War of words: The fight over banning books

""Stop it!" said cartoonist Art Spiegelman. "I mean, talk about Orwellian, you know? Calling this organization Moms for Liberty, when it's actually for suppression, is about as basic as you could find in '1984,' which I think is listed as a young adult novel still, and probably has been banned in lots of places."

Spiegelman has been speaking out ever since the McMinn County, Tennessee school board voted unanimously last year to ban "Maus," his Pulitzer Prize-winning graphic novel about the Holocaust, citing violence, profanity, and (because of the below, right image) nudity. 

Spiegelman said, "I think it's possible for an adult to say, 'I don't want my kid reading that book in class.' But to forbid the other kids from reading it or taking it out of the library? That's not liberty; that's suppression and authoritarianism."

Spiegelman says: fight back. "Kick out the damn school boards," he said, "and get school boards in that are more nuanced in what they're doing; getting involved in local politics as necessary to try to protect libraries' funding and schools' needs, instead of making it such a low priority.""